The Best Places to Eat Oysters on the Connecticut Shoreline
As the cool autumn air settles along the Connecticut shoreline, there’s one delicacy that reaches its peak: oysters. Fresh from the briny depths of Long Island Sound, Connecticut oysters are plump, flavorful, and ready to be savored. Whether you’re a seasoned oyster connoisseur or new to these briny bivalves, the Connecticut coast offers an abundance of spots to indulge. From casual seafood shacks to refined waterfront dining, here’s our guide to the best places to eat oysters on the Connecticut shoreline, all with that distinct fall flair.
1. Shell & Bones Oyster Bar & Grill
New Haven, CT
When it comes to coastal dining in New Haven, Shell & Bones is the oyster lover’s paradise. Nestled along the waterfront with panoramic views of the harbor, this restaurant boasts a raw bar that serves oysters straight from Long Island Sound. The oysters here are impeccably fresh, and the setting is perfect for a leisurely fall evening spent by the water. Enjoy them with classic mignonette, or try their unique house-made sauces for a twist.
Pro Tip: Pair your oysters with their house oyster shooter for a bold, briny kick.
2. S&P Oyster Restaurant & Bar
Mystic, CT
In the heart of historic Mystic, S&P Oyster offers stunning views of the Mystic River and a raw bar that showcases the best of the local waters. This spot combines upscale dining with a casual coastal vibe, perfect for a fall outing after exploring Mystic’s charming shops and seaport. Their oysters are harvested from nearby waters and served up fresh, with a side of waterfront views.
Pro Tip: Order their raw oyster platter and follow it with the creamy New England clam chowder—an unbeatable autumn pairing.
3. Abbott’s Lobster in the Rough
Noank, CT
A quintessential Connecticut seafood shack, Abbott’s is where locals and visitors alike come to enjoy oysters with a view. Famous for its lobster rolls, Abbott’s also offers a selection of freshly shucked local oysters during the fall season. The no-frills atmosphere, outdoor picnic tables, and panoramic views of the harbor make this the ideal spot for a casual oyster feast.
Pro Tip: Enjoy oysters on the half shell with a cup of their renowned clam chowder, and catch the sunset over the water for an unforgettable evening.
4. The Guilford Mooring
Guilford, CT
Set along the scenic Guilford waterfront, The Guilford Mooring offers a sophisticated take on shoreline dining. Their raw bar features an ever-changing selection of local oysters, including varieties harvested straight from Long Island Sound. The restaurant’s cozy interior and autumnal ambiance make it a perfect spot for a relaxed evening of oyster tasting as the leaves start to turn.
Pro Tip: Try their signature oyster shooter—vodka, cocktail sauce, and a freshly shucked oyster—perfectly paired with a fall sunset.
5. Liv’s Oyster Bar
Old Saybrook, CT
As the name suggests, Liv’s Oyster Bar in Old Saybrook is a haven for oyster aficionados. With a focus on local, sustainable seafood, this elegant spot serves up freshly shucked oysters with a variety of accompaniments. Liv’s cozy, refined atmosphere makes it the perfect destination for a fall date night or a celebratory meal, with oysters taking center stage on the menu.
Pro Tip: Go for a dozen oysters on the half shell, then indulge in their signature lobster mac and cheese for a decadent fall feast.
6. Fresh Salt at Saybrook Point Resort & Marina
Old Saybrook, CT
For a truly upscale oyster experience, Fresh Salt at Saybrook Point Resort offers both luxury and sustainability. The restaurant sources its oysters from nearby Long Island Sound, serving them at their prime during the fall months. With breathtaking views of the Connecticut River, Fresh Salt offers an elegant atmosphere, perfect for an indulgent evening of fine dining.
Pro Tip: For a showstopper, order the raw bar tower, which includes a mix of local oysters, shrimp, clams, and lobster. Pair with a crisp glass of Champagne.
7. Stony Creek Brewery
Branford, CT
For a more relaxed, casual experience, head to Stony Creek Brewery in Branford. While known for its craft beer, Stony Creek often hosts oyster pop-ups featuring fresh, locally harvested oysters. Sip on a seasonal brew while enjoying freshly shucked oysters on their outdoor patio with sweeping views of the Branford River. It’s the perfect spot for a laid-back oyster and beer pairing on a cool fall day.
Pro Tip: Keep an eye out for their fall events like “Docktoberfest,” where you can enjoy craft beers paired with local oysters and live music.
Where to Buy Fresh Oysters on the Connecticut Shoreline
If you’d rather shuck and serve oysters at home, Connecticut has a variety of local seafood markets where you can pick up the freshest oysters for your own fall oyster party. Here are a few of the top spots:
Atlantic Seafood Market (Old Saybrook) – Known for carrying the freshest local oysters, this market is a go-to for preparing your own Connecticut oyster feast at home.
Fall is the perfect time to indulge in the bounty of Long Island Sound’s finest oysters. Whether you’re dining out along the Connecticut shoreline or hosting your own oyster tasting at home, you’ll experience the unique flavors of Connecticut’s coastal waters. So pull up a seat, grab a shucking knife, and enjoy the taste of fall in every briny bite.
IT’S A GOOD READ!
Recent Articles
It would be a shame to miss out!
Follow us @shoreline_ct for even more content.
Looking for the perfect fall indulgence? Al Roker's Bourbon Apple Pie Milkshake from his new cookbook Recipes to Live By blends the rich flavors of apple pie, creamy vanilla ice cream, and a splash of bourbon. This decadent treat is the ultimate way to savor the season. Grab the recipe and cozy up with this autumn delight!